The CFP Board said it has submitted a comment letter to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority over its proposal to modernize FINRA’s arbitration rules, guidances, and processes
The authority sought public comment on the initiative published in Regulatory Notice 26-06, in which it detailed some of the key areas of concern to its arbitration forum. Feedback was requested on a number of topics, including the use of clauses that require customers to address disputes through arbitration, whether certain claims should have different procedural requirements, and if customers should have more freedom to opt for litigation over arbitration.
In its comment letter, the CFP Board emphasized the critical need for FINRA to solve what it called the serious problem of unpaid arbitration awards. “It is unacceptable that approximately one in four arbitration awards granted to investors who win arbitration proceedings goes entirely uncollected, with approximately 37 cents of every dollar awarded remaining unpaid,” the board stated.
The letter asserts that this current practice is “not sustainable for the everyday American”, adding that consumers who have been harmed should not be left without meaningful recovery. According to the board, FINRA has many potential solutions (such as insurance or a dedicated fund) that are both affordable and effective. FINRA’s failure to implement one of these solutions undermines consumer trust in financial advice, the letter said.
“FINRA should consider whether its existing rules and supervisory tools sufficiently ensure that member firms have the financial capacity to satisfy arbitration awards”. the CFP Board said. “Current net capital requirements may not adequately reflect potential liability arising from customer claims, particularly for firms with significant customer exposure or a history of complaints. As a result, some investors pursue claims through lengthy and resource-intensive proceedings only to learn – after prevailing – that recovery is unlikely.”
The board encouraged FINRA to work with the SEC to evaluate whether broker-dealer financial responsibility requirements should be recalibrated to better account for arbitration risk. This consideration could include enhanced capital expectations for firms with elevated complaint histories or material pending claims, as well as earlier identification of firms whose financial condition may impair their ability to satisfy an award. The letter encourages FINRA to continue evaluating the potential role of an industry-wide recovery mechanism to address unpaid awards where respondents lack sufficient resources.
The CFP Board’s comments also focused on two other areas that it called especially consequential for investor protection and professional accountability, including preserving existing safeguards around motions to dismiss and strengthening and modernizing FINRA’s Arbitration Awards Online (AAO) database. In each of these areas, CFP Board urges FINRA to prioritize reforms that enhance transparency, reduce information asymmetries, and ensure that arbitration outcomes are fair for investors.
Hyman Cotter PC represents advisors, brokers and other financial professional in all matters involving the CFP Board, including CFP Board investigations. Headquartered in Chicago, our securities attorneys represent clients nationwide. For more information relating to CFP Board investigations and discipline or other matters, contact Hyman Cotter at (833) 665-0784 or through our online contact form for a free consultation.
